The
Saber-Tooth Curriculum
Fish-grabbing,
Wolly-horse-clubbing, Saber-tooth-tiger-scaring, Oh My! You wouldn’t think a
book that expounds on an ancient civilization’s survival techniques and how
they teach them to their young would fit in with the state of our educational
system today, but that’s exactly what this book does.
The Saber-Tooth Curriculum is a book that
excoriates the inefficiency in the American education system at the time that
it was published in 1939. Written by an author who had been a school
superintendent, assistant professor of education, assistant dean, and dean of
the college of education, a few titles held by the esteemed Harold R.W. Benjamin.
Benjamin wrote under the pseudonym J. Abner Peddiwell after the publishers
decided the book should be published as a stunt, not as serious educational
material but in a tongue-in-cheek manner to cautiously test reader reaction. It
uses a satirical format of a student running into his old professor at a
tourist bar in Tijuana and the professor’s subsequent lectures on the
educational affairs of that prehistoric society. An educational process he
names ‘The Saber-Tooth Curriculum.’ The lectures go into how the traditions of
schooling can be so dutifully followed that even in the midst of environmental and
cultural changes, an educational system can resist needed changes for the
society to survive. Peddiwell –er- Benjamin believed that the education of his
times were not responsive enough, or flexible enough to the burgeoning needs of
the culture of that time. Much of what he wrote can extrapolate to our current
educational state. He speaks of the elders, or those in charge, doing things
the same way over & over because they’ve always been done that way. The
religion of tradition, I call it, and none can waver.
Looking
at how I as an educator can apply the lessons Benjamin sought to bring to light
in his satirical book, I think first I can begin to develop ways to bring
living into learning. I can think of ways that learning experiences in life can
be brought into the classroom by way of problem solving projects, group
projects, and technological tools that we use in everyday life. To look at my
students as curious and inquisitive learners who need a guide to help them to
discover knowledge more than just content.
In
today’s education I believe there is less rigidity to hang onto old ways, but
much like a large ocean-liner, the effort and amount of time it takes to change
course is not going to happen overnight. There does seem to be more schools, superintendents,
deans, and elders willing to accept the fact that we are constantly learning
about human behavior and how we learn and look for ways to bring that additive knowledge
and understanding into our classrooms. No longer can “academia” set firmly in
place the capstone onto the pillar of innovative education, if we are to
produce learners who know how to do the things our community needs to have done
– while not extinguishing their energy and will that it takes to go do them.
I like your analogy to a large ocean liner. I agree that educators are starting to see the need for change, but that it will take time. Just curious what subject you teach and what are some of the real world problems that you have possibly presented to your students? Love this interpretation of the second principle.
ReplyDeleteThanks Kim, the one 'real world problem' I thought of is instead of having my students type up a one page word doc to tell me about fun things to do in the area, I'm going to present to them that one of our newest staff moved here from out of town and is looking for fun things to do - they'll need to type up their fun things to do, print them out and then I will deliver to that staff person. Hopefully as an exit (to put a ribbon on it) I can get that staff member to come and thank the class for their list of things to do.
DeleteI am officially the Technology Specialist - In addition to being help desk/fix it guy and running A/V for all of our special events, I teach a 'technology' class once a week for 23 classes. Elementary & high-school aged students.
DeleteHey Jim! I appreciate that you put lots of effort into preserving the natural curiosity that students have - it's so so important that they are eager to learn or else we as teachers have no chance of doing our jobs. Yes, people are starting to understand that the 'religion of tradition' method isn't really working for our schools, yet our solution is to bring in more elder-roles to analyze and study things.
ReplyDeleteThank You. Ugh... analyse and study, not action! It's in the doing that things get done!
DeleteI agree with your ocean-liner analogy and believe that change is a slow to grow process, both for the administration at the county level, to the school level, and for each grade level team to each teacher within a classroom. I applaud that you are thinking of ways to bring living into learning and of ways that learning experiences in life can be brought into your classroom. Have you had any specific ideas of any problem solving projects or group projects that you can do with your students? I struggle with this as a librarian. "I look at my students as curious and inquisitive learners who need a guide to help them to discover knowledge more than just content" was such a powerful statement.
ReplyDeleteThanks Kim, the one 'real world problem' I thought of is instead of having my students type up a one page word doc to tell me about fun things to do in the area, I'm going to present to them that one of our newest staff moved here from out of town and is looking for fun things to do - they'll need to type up their fun things to do, print them out and then I will deliver to that staff person. Hopefully as an exit (to put a ribbon on it) I can get that staff member to come and thank the class for their list of things to do. Hmmm... projects to do in the library, do you ever have any organizational problems, like we've got 100 books to fit into this space, how are we going to do it? or maybe a book is misplaced and to find it they have to do like a scavenger hunt - but the clues are book titles they have to locate which leads to the next clue? I don't know, just throwing ideas out there.
DeleteThanks for the brainstorming ideas Jim!
DeleteJim,
ReplyDeleteI noticed that Stacey, you and I had a great dialogue on my "pickle post". When I went to write my response, it got too long to post in the comments section, so I made it into a separate post. It's here:
http://zacharycyphers.blogspot.com/2016/09/week-3-productive-contributing-members.html
Jim, I've always been impressed by what school ETs do. I think their role in education is under appreciated. Your work is so important because you teach knowledge and skills that students can employ across all of your classes. It's not just about teaching knowledge of a particular version of Excel or Word, but making sure students know how to use a word processing program for whatever profession the go into; making sure they know how to retrieve information for projects they'll work on in school and at work; and making sure that they become responsible consumers and producers of the ubiquitous content that floods our internet-saturated lives.
ReplyDelete